Remember when fantasy football meant arguing with your college roommates about whether to start Tom Brady or Peyton Manning? When the biggest prize was bragging rights and maybe twenty bucks from each person in the league?
Somewhere between 2009 and today, fantasy sports actually underwent a complete makeover—trading its basement-league charm for the bright lights and big money of what looks suspiciously like gambling. The transformation happened so gradually that many participants didn’t notice they’d crossed from casual fan entertainment into something entirely different.
One day, you’re checking your lineup once a week; the next, you’re refreshing DraftKings every five minutes and calculating optimal salary cap strategies like you’re managing a hedge fund. The evolution isn’t just cultural—it’s financial. The North America Fantasy Sports Market is expected to reach $14.91 billion in 2025 and grow at a CAGR of 12.90% to reach $27.36 billion by 2030.
Those friendly neighborhood fantasy leagues have spawned corporate giants: DraftKings generated $4.7 billion in revenue in 2024, a 30% increase from the previous year, while FanDuel reported a whopping $5.79 billion in revenue with $50.8 billion wagered on their platform.
From Fantasy to Sportsbook
The transition from traditional season-long fantasy leagues to daily fantasy sports (DFS) platforms marked the first significant shift toward gambling-like behavior.
Traditional fantasy sports typically involved friends competing over entire seasons with modest entry fees. DFS introduced immediate gratification, larger prize pools, and the ability to play multiple contests daily—characteristics that more closely resemble traditional gambling.
DraftKings and FanDuel account for more than 90% of the DFS market share in the United States. Both companies have since expanded far beyond their fantasy roots. Following the 2018 Supreme Court ruling that legalized sports betting, these platforms leveraged their existing customer bases to become major sportsbook operators. Combined, FanDuel and DraftKings hold 67% market share in online sports betting and casino gaming.
The Research on Gambling Connections
Academic research has identified concerning links between fantasy sports participation and gambling-related problems. A study of 1,556 college students found “an association between fantasy sports participation and gambling problems”, with participants 5X more likely to report at least one DSM-5 criterion for problem gambling.
The data on college students is particularly striking. 75-80% of college students report having gambled in general within the past year, while a 2023 NCAA survey found that nearly 60% of 18- to 22-year-olds had participated in sports betting.
Studies have also found that approximately half of college student-athletes who qualified as at-risk or having gambling problems were found to have participated in fantasy sports wagering. The concern extends beyond individual behavior, as 75% of daily (or almost daily) sports bettors engaged in binge drinking, which is 4 times more than gamblers who do not engage in sports betting.
The Industry Perspective: Skill vs. Chance
Fantasy sports operators maintain that their platforms involve skill rather than chance, distinguishing them from traditional gambling. DraftKings and FanDuel, along with the American government, argue that sports betting does not constitute gambling, as it is a game of skill rather than chance. This classification has significant legal and regulatory implications, as it has allowed fantasy sports to operate under different rules than traditional gambling activities.
The skill argument centers on the research, strategy, and knowledge required to succeed in fantasy sports. Players analyze statistics, injury reports, matchup data, and weather conditions to make informed decisions about their lineups. Successful players often employ sophisticated analytical approaches and maintain detailed records of their performance across different contest types and sports.
Responsible Gaming Measures and Concerns
Both major platforms have implemented responsible gaming tools in response to addiction concerns:
- FanDuel’s approach: Deposit limits, contest entry limits, and naming sports radio host Craig Carton as their first national responsible gaming ambassador.
- DraftKings’ initiatives: Membership in the National Council on Problem Gaming, sponsoring annual NCPG conferences, and providing deposit limits, wagering limits, and time limits
- Industry partnerships: Both companies are Official Sports Betting Partners of major leagues, including the NBA and NFL.
Despite these measures, recent research suggests the scope of gambling addiction may be expanding. Internet searches for gambling addiction help have cumulatively increased 23% nationally since the 2018 Supreme Court ruling, corresponding with approximately 6.5 to 7.3 million searches for gambling addiction help-seeking nationally.
The Cultural & Economic Impact
The fantasy sports evolution has fundamentally changed how fans consume sports content. Participants report increased engagement with games, teams, and players they might not otherwise follow. This enhanced engagement benefits leagues, broadcasters, and the broader sports ecosystem through increased viewership and merchandise sales.
From an economic perspective, the industry has created jobs, generated tax revenue, and attracted significant investment capital. Tax revenue from sports betting has generated nearly $4 billion, while the platforms themselves employ thousands directly and support additional jobs in technology, marketing, and content creation.
However, the economic benefits must be weighed against potential social costs. The National Council on Problem Gambling estimates that nearly 6% of college students have a gambling problem, which is almost double the national average for U.S. adults.
Balancing Innovation & Protection
The fantasy sports industry continues evolving as platforms introduce new game formats, expand into additional sports, and integrate emerging technologies. The challenge lies in maintaining the entertainment value and fan engagement benefits while addressing legitimate concerns about gambling addiction and problem gaming behavior.
While the platforms have successfully created engaging experiences that enhance sports fandom for millions, the research indicates genuine risks that deserve serious consideration and proactive management.
As this industry continues growing, the ongoing challenge will be preserving the positive aspects of fantasy sports participation while developing more effective safeguards for vulnerable users. The data suggests this balance remains a work in progress.
Ready to join leaders who analyze culture’s biggest transformations? Join Rolling Stone Culture Council today.
